# AI Editor RSP — Final QA after owner repair

- Task: `t_f03cad9e`
- Date: 2026-06-03
- QA: 墨测
- Production: https://aieditorrsp.net
- Repo: `/root/projects/aieditorrsp`
- Commit: `4eff4eb80f93cba49e2333a09124d182dbe109c0`
- Deployment worker version: `39c344ff-2b2a-49b6-93c8-adc23ec1bfc2`
- Prior QA_GO: stale, not used as launch clearance
- Verdict: `QA_NO_GO`

## 结论

`QA_NO_GO`。视觉/路由/SEO 主要返修项已有明显改善，但 launch/public promotion 仍不能放行。

阻断原因：
1. Auth/payment 没有完成端到端验收：生产登录入口能跳 Google OAuth，匿名 checkout 能引导登录，但没有测试账号/真实 OAuth callback/session/Stripe Checkout/webhook/D1 entitlement 的闭环证据；父任务 Product Acceptance 已给 `PM_NO_GO`。
2. GA4/Clarity 仍未在生产 runtime 启用：Plausible + 自定义 bridge 存在，但 GA4=false、Clarity=false。
3. Lighthouse mobile LCP 仍超标：LCP 3291.889ms > 2500ms。
4. `/auth` 与 `/checkout` 直接路由为 404；实际可用入口是 `/api/auth/login` 与 `/api/checkout/stripe?...`，但本 QA 要求检查 `/auth` `/checkout`，仍需产品/路由决策。
5. 390px `/editor` 首屏仍看不到核心 Generate 操作，Generate 在上传/Prompt Stack 后方；“edge viewports with Generate below fold”未完全消除。

## Owner 三张截图问题回归

| Owner 问题 | 复验结论 | 证据 |
|---|---|---|
| `/editor` heavy overlay / clipped tool / sidebar | 部分通过。没有横向溢出或工具区域裁切，左侧 prompt stack 在桌面仍占空间但未破坏布局；背景视觉仍偏重，移动端首屏距离 Generate 太远。 | Playwright screenshots: `desktop1366-editor.png`, `mobile390-editor.png` |
| `/library` footer 后还有内容 | 通过。视觉上 footer 是终止区，footer 后未出现用户可见主内容。自动脚本报告的 after-footer 为 Next.js script/route announcer false positive，不计为内容区。 | `desktop1366-library.png` |
| `/templates` split/overlay/sidebar/header inconsistent | 通过。390px 单列，无 sidebar，无横向裁切；header 与主站一致，菜单入口可见。 | `mobile390-templates.png` |

## 功能验收

| 项目 | 状态 | 备注 |
|---|---:|---|
| Landing / public routes | PASS | `/` 200；主导航 Editor/Library/Templates/Pricing 可访问。 |
| Route aliases | PASS | `/editor -> /ai-photo-prompt-editor`、`/library -> /prompt-library`、`/templates -> /ai-photo-editing-prompts` 均 200 after redirect。 |
| `/api/credits` | PASS | 200；返回 `authenticated=false`, `plan=free`, `daily_limit=2`, `paid_enabled=true`, checkout monthly/yearly/credit_pack。 |
| Auth entry | PARTIAL / BLOCKING | `/api/auth/login?return_to=/pricing` 302 到 Google OAuth；未完成 OAuth consent、callback、session、logout、D1 user record。 |
| Checkout entry | PARTIAL / BLOCKING | `/api/checkout/stripe?plan=monthly` 匿名 302 到 login；未完成 authenticated Stripe Checkout、payment success、webhook、entitlement。 |
| `/auth` direct route | FAIL | 404。若不是产品入口，应从 QA 范围中移除；若是 public auth route，应实现/redirect。 |
| `/checkout` direct route | FAIL | 404。若不是产品入口，应从 QA 范围中移除；若是 public checkout route，应实现/redirect。 |
| Library Apply to Editor | PASS | 点击 prompt-library 中 Apply 后跳转到 `/ai-photo-prompt-editor`。 |
| Console errors | PASS | Playwright 5 断点 × 9 页面未捕获 console error/pageerror。 |

## UI / UX / Responsive

断点：1366×768、1440×900、1280×800、390×844、430×932。

| 项目 | 状态 | 备注 |
|---|---:|---|
| 横向滚动 | PASS | 检查页面 `overflowX=0`。 |
| Header consistency | PASS | public 页面共用 RSP / AI Editor RSP 导航系统；移动端有 Menu。 |
| Footer terminal | PASS | 视觉检查 footer 是最后用户可见区；脚本 false positive 来自 Next.js scripts。 |
| `/editor` desktop readability | CONDITIONAL | 工具区可读且未裁切；背景 overlay 仍较强，建议继续降噪。 |
| `/editor` mobile core action | FAIL/P1 | 390px 首屏只到 Prompt Stack，Generate 明显 below fold。 |
| `/templates` mobile | PASS | 单列、无 clipping、无 sidebar。 |
| `/library` desktop | PASS | filter/sidebar 为 category filter，未出现 footer 后内容。 |

## SEO / links

| 项目 | 状态 | 备注 |
|---|---:|---|
| `npm run seo:audit` | PASS | 11 routes，single H1、meta 140–160、canonical、schema、alt 均通过。 |
| Sitemap smoke | PASS | sitemap 11 URLs，全部 200，无 noindex。 |
| robots.txt | PASS | 200。 |
| Meta/canonical | PASS | Playwright DOM 检查主要页面 title/meta/canonical 存在。 |
| Duplicate H1 | PASS | `seo:audit` 与 production DOM 均未发现重复 H1。 |
| Prompt library content floor | PASS in local audit / needs product acceptance note | `seo:audit` counts 1344 words；父 SEO 曾指出 production visible DOM 748，本轮视觉显示支持内容已明显增加，但最终 content-floor 口径需 SEO/PM 接受。 |

## Analytics

| 项目 | 状态 | 备注 |
|---|---:|---|
| Plausible | PASS | runtime `plausible=true`。 |
| Custom bridge | PASS | `window.trackAieRsp` 存在，`__aieRspAnalyticsStatus.events` 包含 page_view / hero_cta_click / tool_start / tool_result / pricing_cta_click。 |
| GA4 | FAIL/P1 | runtime `ga4=false`。 |
| Clarity | FAIL/P1 | runtime `clarity=false`。 |

## Performance

Lighthouse mobile homepage:

- Performance: 0.91
- Accessibility: 0.98
- Best Practices: 1.00
- SEO: 1.00
- LCP: 3291.889ms
- CLS: 0
- TBT: 112ms
- FCP: 1610.2615ms

结论：总体分数可用，但 LCP 仍不达 `<2.5s` gate。

## Security / compliance spot checks

| 项目 | 状态 | 备注 |
|---|---:|---|
| HTTPS | PASS | production HTTPS 可访问。 |
| OAuth redirect URI | PARTIAL | 登录入口 302 到 Google OAuth，redirect_uri 为生产 callback；未记录真实 client_id，报告中统一 `[REDACTED]`。 |
| Stripe Tax / checkout source | PARTIAL | source 中 checkout route 含 automatic_tax/billing/tax_id collection；未做真实 authenticated checkout。 |
| Secrets | PASS | 报告未写真实 secrets/client IDs。 |
| Legal pages | PASS | `/privacy` `/terms` `/refund` `/cookie-policy` `/contact` 200。 |

## 阻断问题

| ID | 严重性 | 描述 | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| QA-BLOCK-001 | P0 | 无真实 OAuth callback/session/D1 user/login/logout 端到端证据；Product Acceptance 为 `PM_NO_GO`。 | backend/product/owner |
| QA-BLOCK-002 | P0 | 无 authenticated Stripe Checkout + webhook entitlement + D1 credits/plan upgrade 端到端证据。 | backend/product/owner |
| QA-BLOCK-003 | P1 | GA4/Clarity 生产 runtime 未启用；若无 waiver，不能进入 launch/public promotion。 | analytics/owner |
| QA-BLOCK-004 | P1 | Lighthouse LCP 3291.889ms，仍高于 2500ms。 | frontend/perf |
| QA-BLOCK-005 | P1 | 390px `/editor` Generate 操作仍明显 below fold。 | frontend/product |
| QA-BLOCK-006 | P2/P1 decision | `/auth` `/checkout` direct routes 404；需决定实现 redirect，或从验收范围中明确移除。 | product/backend |

## 已运行检查

- `kanban_show(t_f03cad9e)`
- `skill_view(kanban-worker)`; `projects/site-qa` preloaded
- Read owner repair brief: `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/owner-repair-brief-20260603.md`
- Parent handoffs: SEO `t_cedb79ee`, compliance `t_7507ce87`, product `t_b9a6056a`
- Telegram START message_id=8006
- `git status --short --branch`; `git rev-parse HEAD`; `git log -1 --oneline`
- `npm run verify`
- `npm run seo:audit`
- `npm run build`
- `npx wrangler deployments list --config wrangler.jsonc`
- curl route smoke: `/`, `/editor`, `/library`, `/templates`, `/pricing`, `/api/credits`, `/auth`, `/checkout`, `/robots.txt`, `/sitemap.xml`, legal pages
- sitemap URL smoke: 11 URLs all 200/no noindex
- Playwright production audit across 5 viewports and 9 pages
- Playwright interactions: pricing links, Sign in redirect, checkout redirect, prompt-library Apply to Editor, editor controls
- Visual screenshot review: desktop `/editor`, desktop `/library`, mobile `/templates`, mobile `/editor`
- Lighthouse mobile homepage

## Artifacts

- Report: `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-owner-repair.md`
- Evidence JSON: `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-owner-repair-evidence.json`
- Audit script: `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-owner-repair-audit.mjs`
- Screenshots: `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-owner-repair-screenshots/`
- Lighthouse: `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/lighthouse/aieditorrsp-home-final-qa-owner-repair.json`

## Next inputs required

1. Provide test Google account / authenticated session evidence, or run an owner-supervised OAuth callback test.
2. Run Stripe Checkout test/live payment through webhook and prove D1 entitlement/credits update after callback.
3. Configure GA4 and Clarity production IDs, or attach explicit owner waiver.
4. Fix or waive LCP > 2.5s.
5. Decide `/auth` and `/checkout` public route policy.
6. Reduce `/editor` mobile path-to-generate or explicitly waive below-fold Generate on 390px.

Final QA stays `QA_NO_GO` until the P0 auth/payment evidence exists and P1 launch gates are fixed or explicitly waived.