# 08F3Q QA Recheck - aieditorrsp Stitch fidelity

- Task: t_154775e0
- Tenant: site-aieditorrsp-20260528
- URL: https://aieditorrsp.net
- Repo: /root/projects/aieditorrsp
- Commit checked: 32154566c47cfe6bae1948290503c9dd27a48df9
- Date: 2026-06-02T13:58:03+00:00
- Verdict: QA_NO_GO / SUPERSEDED_BY_OWNER_NO_GO

## Executive verdict

QA_NO_GO / SUPERSEDED. While the narrow 08F3 production smoke passes for real first-screen tool controls, route/API/SEO/security basics, no horizontal overflow, and LOGIN_REQUIRED status handling, this task was blocked by OWNER NO-GO during execution.

Owner reviewed the live Stitch project and ruled current 08F3 fidelity insufficient: all pages are not 1:1 Stitch fidelity, especially upload treatment, Stitch material images/assets, and performance comparison module. Therefore this report must not be used to approve 08F3. Wait for the new full-page 08F4 rework, then run fresh QA.

Residual evidence below is retained only as diagnostic smoke evidence for 08F3, not as launch approval.

## Evidence run

### Repo / build

```text
$ pwd && git rev-parse HEAD && git status --short && node -v && npm -v
/root/projects/aieditorrsp
32154566c47cfe6bae1948290503c9dd27a48df9
v22.22.0
10.9.4
```

`git status --short` was clean before and after QA temp file cleanup.

```text
$ npm run verify
{"ok":true,"routes":11,"hrefPlaceholders":0,"forbiddenCopy":0,"runtime_architecture":"workers_first_frontend_with_api_stubs"}

$ npm run seo:audit
ok: true
failures: []

$ npm run build
✓ Compiled successfully
✓ Generating static pages (26/26)
OpenNext build complete.
Routes include /, /ai-photo-prompt-editor, /pricing, /privacy, /terms, /robots.txt, /sitemap.xml, /api/health, /api/credits, /api/generate-image.
```

### Production route/API smoke

All checked routes returned 200:

```text
/ 200
/pricing 200
/ai-photo-prompt-editor 200
/chatgpt-photo-editing-prompts 200
/ai-photo-editing-prompts 200
/prompt-library 200
/privacy 200
/terms 200
/cookie-policy 200
/refund 200
/contact 200
/robots.txt 200
/sitemap.xml 200
/api/health 200
/api/credits 200
/api/prompt-templates 200
```

Generate endpoint smoke with a real PNG upload returned the expected quota/auth boundary, not a provider crash:

```text
POST /api/generate-image multipart image+prompt -> 402
{"ok":false,"code":"LOGIN_REQUIRED","message":"Daily anonymous previews are used. Sign in to continue or upgrade to Pro."}
```

Browser UI smoke confirmed the same path after selecting a PNG and clicking GENERATE EDIT:

```text
file state: QA-TEST.PNG
status: LOGIN_REQUIRED / Generation blocked
message: Daily anonymous previews are used. Sign in to continue or upgrade to Pro.
account controls visible: LOGIN WITH GOOGLE, PRO MONTHLY, PRO YEARLY, CREDIT PACK
console errors: 0
```

## Stitch fidelity recheck

Design truth:

- /root/.hermes/reports/site-aieditorrsp-20260528/design/screens/home-desktop.png
- /root/.hermes/reports/site-aieditorrsp-20260528/design/screens/tool-states-desktop.png
- /root/.hermes/reports/site-aieditorrsp-20260528/design/html/home-desktop.html
- /root/.hermes/reports/site-aieditorrsp-20260528/design/html/tool-states-desktop.html

### First viewport

Status: PASS

Observed production first viewport:

- right-side `STUDIO_CONSOLE_V01` is above the fold and visually dominant;
- real upload control is present and accepts file state;
- prompt textarea is present with visible prompt content;
- style prompt cards are visible: Editorial, Product Shot, Social Visual, Cyberpunk;
- quota text is visible: `2 free generations left today`;
- primary action is visible: `GENERATE EDIT`;
- status panel and account/checkout controls are visible below the action.

This satisfies the 08F3 requirement that the first screen is a real tool, not a static marketing hero.

### Official Stitch fidelity

Status: PASS with P1 visual richness residual

Matches official design:

- asymmetric hero: copy left, studio console right;
- sticky dark industrial nav, amber CTA, mint system accents;
- Studio console header/state treatment: `STUDIO_CONSOLE_V01`, `SYSTEM READY`, `IDLE`;
- industrial panel borders, dark surface stack, mono labels;
- prompt/template/card structure tracks the official HTML;
- downstream sections preserve the Stitch system: precision prompt templates, protocol/workflow cards, granular control panel, performance comparisons, safety block, FAQ/footer.

Allowed deviations:

- official Google CDN imagery is not hotlinked/copied;
- the upload/source and comparison visuals use safe CSS/generated frames;
- static Stitch buttons are wired into real links/buttons/API status paths;
- copy is adjusted for SEO/compliance and product accuracy.

P1 residual:

- CSS-generated abstract frames are materially less rich than the official screenshot/contact-sheet photography in the Stitch source. They preserve layout and mood but are not final owned photography. This is not a P0 because the task explicitly allowed safe visual replacement and the functional editor is now real.

## Responsive / overflow

### Desktop 1440px

Status: PASS

CDP evidence:

```json
{
  "viewport": {"w": 1440, "h": 900, "scrollWidth": 1425, "overflowX": false},
  "editor": {"x": 638, "y": 140, "w": 640.5, "h": 988.7},
  "generate": {"x": 1069.5, "y": 738.95, "w": 190, "h": 48},
  "nav": {"display": "flex", "visibility": "visible"}
}
```

### Mobile 390px

Status: PASS with minor P2 density issue

CDP evidence:

```json
{"innerWidth":390,"scrollWidth":375,"bodyScrollWidth":375,"overflowX":false}
```

Visual/browser observations:

- no horizontal overflow;
- hero is single-column and readable;
- editor controls stack vertically and remain usable;
- upload, prompt, template cards, quota, generate button, status, login/pricing controls are visible;
- downstream sections stack correctly.

P2 residual:

- top nav keeps all nav links visible at 390px instead of using a hamburger/drawer; links are small and dense. It is usable and non-overflowing, but touch-target quality is weaker than ideal.

## SEO/security quick smoke

Status: PASS

HTML/metadata evidence:

```json
{
  "title": "AI Image Editor With Prompt Templates | AI RSP",
  "description": "Upload a photo, choose a reusable style prompt, and create prompt-based AI edits for portraits, products, and social visuals.",
  "canonical": "https://aieditorrsp.net",
  "og_title": true,
  "og_image": true,
  "schema": 6,
  "h1_count": 1,
  "ga4": true,
  "plausible": true,
  "clarity": true,
  "placeholder_href_count": 0
}
```

Headers evidence:

```text
HTTP/2 200
strict-transport-security: max-age=31536000; includeSubDomains; preload
content-security-policy: default-src 'self'; ... frame-ancestors 'none'; base-uri 'self'; form-action 'self'; upgrade-insecure-requests
referrer-policy: strict-origin-when-cross-origin
x-content-type-options: nosniff
x-frame-options: DENY
server: cloudflare
```

## Issue list

| ID | Severity | Status | Description | Recommendation |
|---|---:|---|---|---|
| 08F3Q-P1-001 | P1 | Open | Safe CSS/generated frames replace official Stitch photography/contact-sheet richness. | Owner/design review before public polish pass; add owned assets if launch bar requires higher visual fidelity. |
| 08F3Q-P2-001 | P2 | Open | 390px top nav is dense; links are small instead of drawer/hamburger. | Consider mobile drawer or larger tap targets. |

No P0 blockers found.

## Final QA decision

QA_NO_GO / SUPERSEDED_BY_OWNER_NO_GO.

Do not approve 08F3. The narrow smoke evidence shows the current production build is functional enough to diagnose, but owner explicitly superseded this task because the site is not 1:1 with the Stitch project across pages, especially upload treatment, material assets, and performance comparison module.

Next step: wait for full-page 08F4 rework, then run fresh QA against the updated Stitch source and production deployment.