# AI Editor RSP Hero Optimization — Final QA Fan-in

- task_id: t_37136895
- role: 墨测 / Final QA fan-in
- production_url: https://aieditorrsp.net
- repo: /root/projects/aieditorrsp
- checked_at_utc: 2026-06-03T08:28Z
- production_commit: bad3a84a398c89f967998398471c878be16e9011
- verdict: QA_NO_GO

## 1. Final verdict

QA_NO_GO.

The scoped hero layout/product/SEO fixes are mostly verified on production: the original right-panel overflow is fixed on required desktop widths, Generate Edit is visible on 1366x768 / 1440x900 / 1280x800 and 390x844 / 430x932, no account/payment/credit controls appear in the first-screen hero, all public routes return 200, homepage console errors are 0 in Playwright, and SEO audit passes.

Final launch cannot pass because one upstream hard gate is still red: Compliance final recheck returned COMPLIANCE_NO_GO with P0 blockers around live billing/checkout claims, OAuth redirect_uri_mismatch, paid_enabled=true while checkout is broken, and provider/high-resolution export over-claims. Per QA gate rules, any P0 compliance blocker keeps final QA at NO_GO.

## 2. Upstream verdict fan-in

| Gate | Parent task | Verdict | QA handling |
|---|---|---|---|
| Design | t_7c14d39a | DESIGN_CONDITIONAL_GO | Accepted for final QA. Original hero visual P0 fixed; residual items are non-blocking design/product judgment. |
| Product | t_41efc6b1 | PM_GO | Accepted for final QA. Scoped first-screen task clarity passes. |
| SEO | t_a62e3a39 | SEO_GO_WITH_P1_FOLLOWUPS | Accepted for final QA with P1 follow-ups. Homepage SEO contract preserved. |
| Compliance | t_586c83e4 | COMPLIANCE_NO_GO | Blocks final QA. P0 compliance items remain. |

## 3. QA checks run

- Read input brief: /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/input-brief.md
- Read parent reports: design-recheck-final.md, product-recheck-final.md, seo-recheck-final.md, compliance-recheck-final.md
- Browser MCP production check: opened homepage, clicked Generate Edit without upload, confirmed Upload required state; browser_console showed no console messages but 3 blank browser-tool JS exception placeholders, not reproduced in Playwright.
- Playwright production route/viewport/interaction/link/API check: /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-playwright.mjs
- Playwright result JSON: /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-results.json
- Screenshots: /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-screenshots/
- npm run verify
- npm run seo:audit
- Lighthouse: /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-lighthouse.json
- curl smoke for public/legal/API routes and OAuth/checkout redirects
- Visual inspection of current 1366x768 and 390x844 screenshots against the old failing screenshot

## 4. Functional / interaction results

| Check | Result | Evidence |
|---|---:|---|
| Homepage HTTP | PASS | curl / returned 200, total 0.46s |
| Public route smoke | PASS | /, /pricing, /privacy, /terms, /refund, /cookie-policy, /contact, /robots.txt, /sitemap.xml all 200 |
| Internal homepage links | PASS | Playwright checked all internal homepage anchors; no bad status |
| Header desktop nav visible | PASS | 1366/1440/1280 show logo, Editor, Library, Templates, Pricing, Sign In, Get Started |
| Mobile nav entry | PASS | 390 screenshot shows single Menu button; no duplicate menu observed |
| Style prompt interaction | PASS | Product Shot click changed prompt to product-photo prompt |
| Generate without upload | PASS | Shows `UPLOAD_REQUIRED — Upload required — Choose a JPG, PNG, or WebP file before testing generation.` |
| Real uploaded-image generation | NOT RUN | Avoided provider/credit consumption; provider readiness remains under compliance/backend evidence. |
| Auth login | FAIL / inherited P0 | /api/auth/login redirects to Google OAuth `redirect_uri_mismatch` error. |
| Stripe checkout | FAIL / inherited P0 | /api/checkout/stripe?plan=monthly redirects to the same Google OAuth error before checkout. |
| Credits API truthfulness | FAIL / inherited P0 | /api/credits returns paid_enabled:true and checkout links while auth/checkout is broken. |

## 5. Responsive / visual regression

| Viewport | Generate visible | Horizontal overflow | First-screen forbidden account/payment/credit terms | Notes |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---|
| 1920x1080 | PASS | PASS | PASS | Editor panel fits; Generate visible. |
| 1440x900 | PASS | PASS | PASS | Editor panel fits; Generate visible. |
| 1366x768 | PASS | PASS | PASS | Current screenshot fixes old right-panel crop; Generate y=418-466, console y=124-663. |
| 1280x800 | PASS | PASS | PASS | Required desktop target passes. |
| 1024x768 | WARN | PASS | PASS | Generate y=777-825, just below fold; not in original required desktop set, but tablet landscape should be tightened if this breakpoint matters. |
| 768x1024 | PASS | PASS | PASS | Generate visible. |
| 430x932 | PASS | PASS | PASS | Mobile target passes. |
| 390x844 | PASS | PASS | PASS | Mobile target passes; single-column editor, Generate visible. |
| 360x800 | PASS | PASS | PASS | Generate bottom y=808, borderline but reachable. |
| 320x568 | WARN | PASS | PASS | Generate below fold; edge-device improvement recommended. |

Visual QA:
- Current 1366x768 hero is materially better than the user-provided failing screenshot: right editor no longer extends to viewport bottom, Generate is above fold, left H1 is optically aligned with editor top, and first screen is focused on upload/prompt/generate.
- Current 390x844 mobile is single-column with no page-level horizontal overflow. Generate is visible in the first editor screen, but the template strip below it is partially clipped horizontally as a carousel-like row; not a blocker for the scoped hero task.
- Below-fold homepage text still contains `high-resolution exports`, matching compliance P0/P1 concern; not in first-screen hero.

## 6. SEO / route basics

| Check | Result | Evidence |
|---|---:|---|
| npm run verify | PASS | `{ ok:true, routes:11, hrefPlaceholders:0, forbiddenCopy:0 }` |
| npm run seo:audit | PASS | ok:true, failures:[] |
| Homepage title/meta/canonical | PASS | title `AI Image Editor With Prompt Templates | AI RSP`; desc len 125; canonical present |
| Homepage H1 | PASS | one H1: `AI Image Editor With Prompt Templates` |
| JSON-LD / OG / Twitter | PASS | parent SEO recheck verified WebApplication, FAQPage, BreadcrumbList + OG/Twitter |
| Sitemap/robots | PASS | both 200; sitemap route count 11 in parent SEO report |
| Non-home duplicate H1 | P1 follow-up | /ai-photo-prompt-editor, /chatgpt-photo-editing-prompts, /ai-photo-editing-prompts have 2 H1 in production DOM per SEO final recheck and QA rerun. |
| Meta description length | P1/P2 follow-up | Several SEO pages are below 140 chars; homepage desc 125. |

## 7. Performance / console / security basics

| Check | Result | Evidence |
|---|---:|---|
| Playwright console/pageerror | PASS | 0 console warnings/errors and 0 pageErrors across checked routes/home interactions |
| Lighthouse Performance | FAIL/P1 | 57; LCP 12.0s, Speed Index 8.7s, TBT 0ms, CLS 0.004 |
| Lighthouse Accessibility | PASS | 98 |
| Lighthouse Best Practices | PASS | 100 |
| Lighthouse SEO | PASS | 100 |
| HTTPS/security headers | PASS | HSTS, CSP, X-Frame-Options DENY, X-Content-Type-Options nosniff observed on homepage response |
| Public route TTFB | PASS | curl smoke mostly 0.12s-0.46s total; Lighthouse LCP issue appears render/asset-side, not basic availability. |
| Analytics script spot check | PARTIAL | Raw homepage HTML includes plausible.io; GA4/Clarity runtime was not fully verified in this hero final QA scope. |

## 8. Blocking issues

| ID | Severity | Description | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| QA-P0-001 | P0 | Compliance final gate is COMPLIANCE_NO_GO. Production claims live billing/checkout while OAuth/checkout fails with Google redirect_uri_mismatch. | modun/mojie/owner config |
| QA-P0-002 | P0 | /api/credits returns paid_enabled:true and checkout links although login/checkout is not usable. | backend/frontend |
| QA-P0-003 | P0 | Provider/export/credits copy is not consistently preview-safe; `high-resolution exports` remains in homepage body, and provider success copy exists without production provider evidence. | frontend/compliance |

## 9. Non-blocking follow-ups

| ID | Severity | Description |
|---|---|---|
| QA-P1-001 | P1 | Lighthouse Performance 57, LCP 12.0s. Needs performance pass or waiver before broader launch confidence. |
| QA-P1-002 | P1 | Non-home SEO pages have duplicate H1 and short meta descriptions; accepted by SEO as follow-up, but should be fixed for full-site SEO quality. |
| QA-P1-003 | P1 | Paid/pricing/credit amounts and refund/checkout terms need one source of truth before billing is advertised. |
| QA-P2-001 | P2 | 1024x768 and 320x568 do not show Generate within the viewport; original required targets pass, but edge/tablet polish is recommended. |
| QA-P2-002 | P2 | GA4/Clarity runtime verification was not completed in this scoped hero QA; only Plausible script presence was spot-checked. |

## 10. Required next inputs

1. Compliance remediation commit/deploy that removes or gates live billing/checkout claims until production OAuth + Stripe + entitlement/webhook evidence exists.
2. Google OAuth console evidence that `https://aieditorrsp.net/api/auth/callback/google` is registered and production login works.
3. Stripe Checkout test evidence or explicit launch mode with paid checkout disabled and `paid_enabled:false`.
4. Provider generation evidence or explicit provider-disabled/preview-safe launch copy.
5. Optional but recommended: performance pass/waiver for Lighthouse LCP, duplicate H1/meta follow-up, and 320/1024 responsive polish.

## 11. Machine-readable handoff

```json
{
  "qa_verdict": "QA_NO_GO",
  "production_url": "https://aieditorrsp.net",
  "production_commit": "bad3a84a398c89f967998398471c878be16e9011",
  "owner_review_needed": true,
  "p0_blockers": [
    "COMPLIANCE_NO_GO: live billing/checkout claims while OAuth/checkout redirects to Google redirect_uri_mismatch",
    "/api/credits exposes paid_enabled:true and checkout links while login/checkout is broken",
    "Provider/export/credits copy not consistently preview-safe; high-resolution exports remains in homepage body"
  ],
  "p1_followups": [
    "Lighthouse Performance 57 / LCP 12.0s",
    "Non-home duplicate H1 and short meta descriptions",
    "Pricing/credits/refund source-of-truth mismatch"
  ],
  "p2_followups": [
    "Generate below fold at 1024x768 and 320x568 edge breakpoints",
    "GA4/Clarity runtime not fully verified in scoped hero QA"
  ],
  "checks_run": [
    "kanban_show(t_37136895)",
    "skill_view(kanban-worker)",
    "read input brief and four parent final reports",
    "browser_navigate production homepage",
    "browser click Generate Edit without upload",
    "browser_console",
    "Playwright route/viewport/interaction/link/API QA",
    "npm run verify",
    "npm run seo:audit",
    "npx lighthouse production homepage",
    "curl public/legal/API/OAuth/checkout smoke",
    "visual review of 1366x768 and 390x844 screenshots"
  ],
  "artifact_paths": [
    "/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa.md",
    "/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-results.json",
    "/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-playwright.mjs",
    "/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-lighthouse.json",
    "/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-screenshots/"
  ],
  "residual_risk": [
    "Final QA cannot override Compliance P0; launch remains blocked until compliance fixes are deployed and rechecked.",
    "Real uploaded-image generation, authenticated entitlement, and Stripe webhook were not completed because OAuth is broken and provider/credit consumption was avoided.",
    "Lighthouse performance is below QA threshold and needs fix or explicit waiver."
  ],
  "next_inputs": [
    "Compliance remediation deploy",
    "OAuth redirect URI production evidence",
    "Stripe checkout/end-to-end paid entitlement evidence or paid-disabled launch mode",
    "Provider generation evidence or preview-safe provider-disabled mode",
    "Re-QA request after P0 fixes"
  ]
}
```