# 07G Product Acceptance Recheck After Provider Repair — aieditorrsp

- task_id: t_564f9c20
- tenant: site-aieditorrsp-20260528
- project_slug: aieditorrsp
- domain: https://aieditorrsp.net
- checked_at_utc: 2026-05-29T08:05:42Z
- prepared_by: 墨策
- repo_commit_checked: ca5e9d3e846a069bc44c162a0b05090f652001d3
- deployment_version_checked: 4230b57f-f7d3-4459-93c6-315f68287e89
- evidence_api_smoke: /root/.hermes/kanban/boards/site-factory/workspaces/t_564f9c20/07g-api-smoke.json
- evidence_route_smoke: /root/.hermes/kanban/boards/site-factory/workspaces/t_564f9c20/07g-route-smoke.json

## Verdict: PM_NO_GO

Provider repair is verified: production `/api/generate-image` now returns a real provider success for a safe image edit request, including `ok:true`, `image_url`, `preview_url`, and `download_url`.

But product acceptance still cannot pass. The production UI still does not expose a real upload/result-preview flow on the checked deployed pages, key CTA/navigation items remain inert or homepage fallbacks, and public compliance/payment copy is stale after provider enablement. Final QA / launch must stay blocked until frontend interaction repair and provider-compliance copy repair are deployed and rechecked.

## Required recheck results

| Gate | Result | Evidence | PM decision |
|---|---:|---|---|
| Safe `/api/generate-image` returns real provider result | PASS | HTTP 200 in 13.95s; body has `ok:true`, `provider:"fal"`, `model:"fal-ai/flux-pro/kontext"`, `image_url`, `preview_url`, `download_url`, `request_id:"019e72c4-f10f-7941-9890-a034c1c252bc"`. | Provider blocker from 07C is cleared. |
| Unsafe prompt blocked before provider call | PASS | HTTP 400; body `ok:false`, `code:"UNSAFE_PROMPT_BLOCKED"`, message says blocked safety category. | Safety precheck remains acceptable. |
| `/api/credits` reports paid checkout disabled | PASS | HTTP 200; body `plan:"free"`, `daily_limit:2`, `remaining:2`, `paid_enabled:false`. | Payment remains disabled; acceptable for preview, not paid launch. |
| Upload source image from production UI | FAIL | Browser DOM inspection on `/` and `/ai-photo-prompt-editor` found `input[type=file]` count = 0. | 07C frontend blocker remains live in production. |
| Result preview/download from production UI | FAIL | API can return URLs, but deployed UI pages do not expose a real upload/generate/result path; no `.preview-repair` component present in production DOM. | User task still fails. |
| Public legal/payment copy after provider enablement | FAIL | `/privacy`, `/terms`, `/pricing`, `/refund`, `/cookie-policy` still contain provider-pending / provider-disabled or storage-overclaim wording called out by 07F. | Compliance copy blocker remains; t_5c0f6d38 is running. |

## API smoke evidence

### `/api/credits`

```json
{
  "http_status": 200,
  "body": {
    "plan": "free",
    "daily_limit": 2,
    "remaining": 2,
    "paid_enabled": false
  }
}
```

### Unsafe generation

```json
{
  "http_status": 400,
  "body": {
    "ok": false,
    "code": "UNSAFE_PROMPT_BLOCKED",
    "message": "This request matches a blocked safety category."
  }
}
```

### Safe generation

```json
{
  "http_status": 200,
  "elapsed_seconds": 13.95,
  "body": {
    "ok": true,
    "provider": "fal",
    "model": "fal-ai/flux-pro/kontext",
    "request_id": "019e72c4-f10f-7941-9890-a034c1c252bc",
    "image_url": "https://v3b.fal.media/files/b/0a9c20e6/wwmXuFfib9WyeDDPky083_c685d797505a404285b5451ce08f2566.png",
    "preview_url": "https://v3b.fal.media/files/b/0a9c20e6/wwmXuFfib9WyeDDPky083_c685d797505a404285b5451ce08f2566.png",
    "download_url": "https://v3b.fal.media/files/b/0a9c20e6/wwmXuFfib9WyeDDPky083_c685d797505a404285b5451ce08f2566.png",
    "compliance": {
      "unsafe_prompt_blocked_before_provider": true,
      "site_storage": "none",
      "result_cache_ttl_hours": 24
    }
  }
}
```

## 07C blocker update

| 07C blocker | Current status after provider repair | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| `PROVIDER_NOT_CONFIGURED` blocks safe generation | Fixed. Safe production request now returns real fal result URLs. | Cleared. |
| No detectable file input in rendered production UI | Still present. `/` has 0 file inputs; `/ai-photo-prompt-editor` has 0 file inputs. | Blocking. |
| No generated result preview/download path | Still present at UI level. API returns URLs, but user cannot reach the flow through production UI. | Blocking. |
| Inert/fallback links/buttons | Still present. Examples: homepage `Templates`, `VIEW_ALL_LIBRARY`, footer `Dashboard`, `API Docs`, `Compliance`, `Security` point to `/`; editor sidebar links also fall back to `/`. | Blocking / cleanup before final QA. |
| Paid checkout disabled | Still disabled. | Acceptable for preview scope; not acceptable for paid launch. |
| Compliance provider/retention copy | Newly blocking after provider enablement per 07F. | Blocking until public copy fix deploys. |

## User task acceptance

1. “I want to edit a photo with a prompt.” — FAIL.
   - API can edit a posted image.
   - Production UI still does not provide a real file upload/generate/result flow.

2. “I want unsafe/deceptive edits blocked.” — PASS.
   - Unsafe prompt returned `UNSAFE_PROMPT_BLOCKED` before provider success path.

3. “I want to know free/paid state before trying.” — PARTIAL PASS.
   - `/api/credits` truthfully reports `paid_enabled:false`.
   - Pricing/refund/cookie public copy is stale because it still says provider generation is disabled, while provider generation is now enabled.

4. “I want to download the edited result.” — FAIL from UI, PASS by raw API.
   - Raw API returns `download_url`.
   - Production UI does not expose a completed result/download state to normal users.

5. “I want reusable prompt templates.” — PASS.
   - `/api/prompt-templates` returns 20 templates; prompt library route is reachable.

## Related active repair tasks

Existing board state already has the correct downstream owners in flight:

- `t_336249d9` — `07D aieditorrsp PM NO-GO frontend interaction repair`, assignee `mojie`, status `running`.
- `t_5c0f6d38` — `07F1 aieditorrsp provider compliance public-copy fix`, assignee `mojie`, status `running`.
- `t_1ced1a6d` — `08 aieditorrsp final QA`, assignee `motest`, status `todo`; must remain gated until frontend/compliance/PM blockers close.

No new task is created by this PM recheck because the needed repair cards already exist.

## Next gate

`PM_NO_GO_REPAIR_STILL_REQUIRED`.

Do not unlock final QA / launch. Re-run PM acceptance after:

1. frontend repair is deployed and production pages expose real upload → generate → result preview/download;
2. provider compliance public copy is deployed and 07F copy defects are cleared;
3. final production commit/deployment version is known and synchronized.

## Verification performed

- Loaded Kanban task context and parent handoffs.
- Sent `[START]` to Telegram topic `telegram:-1003750190535:5318`.
- Read 07C prior PM report, 07E provider repair report, and 07F compliance recheck.
- Checked repo HEAD: `ca5e9d3e846a069bc44c162a0b05090f652001d3`.
- Noted `/root/projects/aieditorrsp` is dirty with frontend repair files not reflected in the current production deployment.
- Created local source test image: `/root/.hermes/kanban/boards/site-factory/workspaces/t_564f9c20/source-test.png`.
- Ran production `/api/credits`, unsafe `/api/generate-image`, and safe `/api/generate-image` smoke checks.
- Browser-inspected `/` and `/ai-photo-prompt-editor` production DOM for file inputs, result component, links, and button state.
- Extracted `/privacy`, `/terms`, `/pricing`, `/refund`, and `/cookie-policy` to confirm copy blockers remain.
- Checked `/api/prompt-templates` returns 20 templates.