# 08G Final QA Recheck — aieditorrsp

Verdict: QA_GO

Reviewed at: 2026-05-29 UTC
Tenant: site-aieditorrsp-20260528
Domain: https://aieditorrsp.net
Repo: /root/projects/aieditorrsp
Commit verified: 1ac5cec0727650425d2807052f6ae433ec673d00
Scope: production-only final QA recheck after 08F frontend remediation

## Bottom line

QA_GO for paid launch from the final frontend/compliance recheck scope.

The 08E P0 blockers are fixed in production: legal paid-state contradictions are gone, pricing header/footer and card layout are visually stable, the 390px editor no longer exposes the old duplicate/squeezed editor, production Tailwind CDN warning is gone, required routes/APIs are healthy, checkout/auth redirects work, webhook endpoint exists, and unsafe prompt blocking happens before provider validation.

Residual risk remains: Lighthouse Performance passes >=80, but LCP is still 3.4s in this run, above the ideal 2.5s target. No authenticated test session was available, so authenticated Stripe Checkout redirect and successful provider-consuming generation were source-level/code-path confirmed only; no real payment or provider-consuming generation was executed.

## Gate results

| Area | Status | Evidence |
|---|---:|---|
| Route 200 smoke | GO | `/`, editor, SEO pages, pricing, legal pages, `robots.txt`, `sitemap.xml`, `/api/health`, `/api/credits`, `/api/prompt-templates` returned 200. `/api/webhooks/stripe` returned 405 to GET, confirming endpoint exists and does not expose GET. |
| API health / paid credits | GO | `/api/health` returned `ok:true`, runtime `cloudflare-workers-opennext`, version `frontend-launch`. `/api/credits` returned `paid_enabled:true`, free daily limit 2, and checkout routes for monthly/yearly/credit_pack. |
| SEO audit regression | GO | `npm run seo:audit` passed 11 routes: rendered alt missing total 0, canonical/OG/sitemap checks passed, expected schema present on SEO pages. Production page audit found title/meta/canonical/single H1/OG tags. |
| Sitemap checks | GO | Production sitemap contains 11 URLs; sampled all listed URLs as 200 with no `noindex` hit. |
| Paid compliance copy | GO | Production forbidden-copy scan found no stale disabled/planned/private-preview/waitlist/Tailwind CDN hits on `/`, `/pricing`, editor, `/privacy`, `/terms`, `/refund`, `/contact`. Pricing/privacy/terms/refund contain required Stripe/tax/Nextfield disclosure where applicable. |
| Pricing desktop visual | GO | Browser desktop 1440px: header nav visible and spaced; four pricing cards aligned in one row; footer legal links spaced and readable; no horizontal overflow. Screenshot: `/root/.hermes/profiles/motest/cache/screenshots/browser_screenshot_0e039321451147c080deee7e66fe6962.png`. |
| Mobile editor 390px usability | GO with P2 polish | DOM check: no horizontal overflow, single H1, controls stacked/readable, old duplicate raw editor no longer present as competing UI. Native file upload control remains visually small; nav links are readable but compact. Screenshot: `/root/.hermes/profiles/motest/cache/screenshots/browser_screenshot_1c5d2698b87646849ad5bf5f192f71d7.png`. |
| Hydration/load jump/flicker | GO | Reloaded editor page after installing in-page error listeners; `document.readyState=complete`, no captured `error`/`unhandledrejection`, navigation duration ~722ms. No visible duplicate editor jump in static/mobile inspection. |
| Console errors | GO with note | In-page error listeners on reload captured no site errors. Browser tool still reported blank JS exceptions, but DOM inspection shows injected `monica-content-root` extension; right-edge floating widgets in screenshots are browser extension pollution, not site DOM. No `cdn.tailwindcss.com` warning observed. |
| Anonymous checkout redirects | GO | `monthly`, `yearly`, and `credit_pack` checkout URLs return 302 to `/api/auth/login?return_to=/api/checkout/stripe?...`. |
| OAuth login starts correctly | GO | `/api/auth/login?return_to=/pricing` returns 302 to Google OAuth with callback `https://aieditorrsp.net/api/auth/callback/google`, scope `openid email profile`, and secure HttpOnly/SameSite state cookie. |
| Webhook endpoint | GO | Source verifies `stripe-signature` before processing; GET returns 405. |
| Unsafe prompt blocks before provider | GO | Multipart POST with explicit unsafe prompt + dummy image returned 400 `UNSAFE_PROMPT_BLOCKED`. Safe prompt without image returned 400 `IMAGE_REQUIRED`, verifying validation path without provider use. |
| Successful generation | CODE_GO / NOT_E2E | No authenticated test session available. Source confirms provider call only after prompt/image/credit checks; credits are committed only after FAL returns an output URL; failures/timeouts do not commit credits. |
| Performance | GO with residual risk | Lighthouse home: Performance 86, Accessibility 100, Best Practices 100, SEO 100, CLS 0.006, LCP 3.4s. Performance threshold passes; LCP still above ideal target. |

## Commands and checks run

```bash
git rev-parse HEAD
# 1ac5cec0727650425d2807052f6ae433ec673d00

git status --short
# clean before QA artifact generation; repo report artifacts are gitignored

npm run verify
# {"ok":true,"routes":11,"hrefPlaceholders":0,"forbiddenCopy":0,"runtime_architecture":"workers_first_frontend_with_api_stubs"}

npm run seo:audit
# ok=true; 11 routes passed; no rendered image alt failures; no SEO audit failures

npx lighthouse https://aieditorrsp.net --output=json --output-path=reports/08g-lighthouse-home.json --chrome-flags='--headless --no-sandbox' --quiet
# Performance 86 / Accessibility 100 / Best Practices 100 / SEO 100 / LCP 3.4s / CLS 0.006
```

Production HTTP/API/compliance scan artifact:
- `/root/projects/aieditorrsp/reports/08g-production-http-seo-compliance.json`

Lighthouse artifacts:
- `/root/projects/aieditorrsp/reports/08g-lighthouse-home.json`
- `/root/projects/aieditorrsp/reports/08g-lighthouse-summary.txt`

## Fixed 08E blockers rechecked

1. Legal paid-state contradiction: fixed. No `paid checkout is disabled`, `PLANNED / DISABLED`, `paid credits remain disabled`, `provider pending`, `not enabled yet`, `Private preview`, `waitlist`, `$0/day`, or `cdn.tailwindcss.com` hits in the scanned production pages.
2. Pricing header/footer: fixed. Desktop nav/footer links are visible, spaced, and not concatenated/clipped.
3. Pricing cards/billing flow: fixed enough for launch. Cards are aligned; CTAs and billing/tax disclosure are coherent.
4. 390px editor: fixed enough for launch. Single canonical live editor flow; no squeezed legacy top editor; no site horizontal overflow.
5. Production Tailwind CDN warning / blank site exceptions: fixed from site evidence. Browser-level blank exceptions appear polluted by installed extensions; in-page reload listener captured no site errors.
6. Homepage performance: materially improved from 08E Performance 56 / LCP 17.3s to Performance 86 / LCP 3.4s. LCP remains a residual optimization item.
7. Authenticated paid checkout/generation E2E: not executed because no authenticated test session was provided and no real payment/provider-consuming flow should be run from QA.

## Residual risk

- P1/P2: LCP remains above the ideal 2.5s target at 3.4s, despite Performance passing 86. Recommend post-launch or pre-scale optimization of hero render/bundle path.
- P2: Mobile header nav links are compact and native file upload control is visually small; usable, but polish can improve.
- Not tested E2E: authenticated Stripe Checkout session creation and successful provider-consuming generation/credit deduction. Source confirms intended behavior; needs test account/session if owner wants full paid E2E proof before launch.
- Browser visual screenshots include right-edge floating widgets from a browser extension (`monica-content-root`), not site DOM. Do not treat those widgets as site defects.

## Next inputs

- Optional owner decision: accept LCP 3.4s residual risk or request one more frontend performance pass.
- Optional test credential/session: provide authenticated Google test session if full Stripe test Checkout and provider-consuming successful generation must be validated before launch.

## Final result

QA_GO