# AI Editor RSP — Final Re-QA closeout recheck

- Task: `t_5ef908c5`
- Production: https://aieditorrsp.net
- Generated: 2026-06-04T08:21:46Z
- Status: BLOCKED / SUPERSEDED BEFORE FINAL VERDICT
- QA verdict: NOT_ISSUED

## Blocking state

This Final Re-QA was interrupted by a newer Owner/Product gate failure while checks were running.

Current Kanban source of truth:

- `t_5ef908c5` is already `blocked`.
- Block reason: `OWNER_FEEDBACK_P0_PRODUCT_UX`.
- Owner/Product feedback says the core editor and paid conversion are not acceptable yet: upload preview missing, weak loading/style selection, generated image preview/download missing, account/credits surface missing, paid conversion unreviewed.
- Product deep review `t_2bd28b27` completed with `PM_NO_GO` and created repair tasks.
- Frontend repair `t_f03c74e9` is still running at the time this report was written.

Therefore this run must not issue `QA_GO` or `QA_CONDITIONAL_GO`. A fresh Final Re-QA should be created only after the product/repair children complete and production deploy is stable.

## Partial checks completed before supersession

Evidence files:

- `/root/.hermes/kanban/boards/site-review/workspaces/t_5ef908c5/final_reqa_audit.js`
- `/root/.hermes/kanban/boards/site-review/workspaces/t_5ef908c5/final_reqa_evidence.json`
- `/root/.hermes/kanban/boards/site-review/workspaces/t_5ef908c5/lighthouse-home-final-closeout.json`
- `/root/.hermes/kanban/boards/site-review/workspaces/t_5ef908c5/lighthouse-home-mobile-final-closeout.json`

Important caveat: these partial checks were captured before the latest frontend repair commit/deploy finished. Treat them as historical evidence only, not as final launch evidence.

### Repo / local gates

- `npm run verify`: PASS
  - routes=11
  - hrefPlaceholders=0
  - forbiddenCopy=0
  - analyticsRuntimeHooks=11
- `npm run seo:audit`: PASS
  - 11 audited routes
  - single H1 per route
  - canonical / OG / sitemap / schema / alt checks passed

Repo later moved while another worker was running:

- Earlier observed clean state: `7b3ba5d0f497facd7e5daa71abfbb29e6e52ac48`
- Later observed repo head: `70cdaec49030ae7d0dc754a0bdc09d72f386bfac` (`fix: repair core editor ux conversion path`)
- Latest observed Cloudflare deployment still reported Worker version `d715d316-6838-433b-9826-a7d11576a6c5` with Source Unknown at the time checked.

Fresh Re-QA must re-check source/deploy same-commit after `t_f03c74e9` completes.

### Production route smoke

Partial HTTP route results:

- `/`: 200
- `/ai-photo-prompt-editor`: 200
- `/pricing`: 200
- `/privacy`: 200
- `/terms`: 200
- `/cookie-policy`: 200
- `/refund`: 200
- `/contact`: 200
- `/robots.txt`: 200
- `/sitemap.xml`: 200
- `/auth`: 308 -> `/api/auth/login?return_to=%2Fpricing`
- `/checkout`: 308 -> `/pricing`
- `/editor`: 308 -> `/ai-photo-prompt-editor`

Sitemap sampled 11 URLs, all returned 200 and no `noindex` was found.

Robots note: `robots.txt` allows `/` and only disallows `/api/checkout` and `/api/stripe`; the partial script's `robotsAllowsCore=false` was a conservative regex false positive, not a core-page block.

### Browser/runtime checks

Playwright checks across desktop 1440 and mobile 390 found:

- Console/page errors: 0
- Horizontal overflow: false
- Home desktop Sign in visible: true
- Stale `Preview access` copy on home desktop: false
- Clarity requests observed: 43
- Plausible requests observed: 14
- GA4 requests observed: 0

GA4 remains an external configuration gap already recorded by SEO/Product as conditional risk:

- Missing `NEXT_PUBLIC_GA_MEASUREMENT_ID` / GA4 Measurement ID or Analytics Admin-capable access.
- Clarity and Plausible are live.

### LCP / Lighthouse

Partial performance checks:

- Playwright PerformanceObserver mobile home LCP: 1108 ms
- Playwright PerformanceObserver desktop home LCP: 560 ms
- Lighthouse desktop:
  - Performance 99
  - Accessibility 98
  - Best Practices 100
  - SEO 100
  - LCP 843 ms
  - CLS 0
- Lighthouse mobile simulated:
  - Performance 93
  - Accessibility 98
  - Best Practices 100
  - SEO 100
  - LCP 3035 ms
  - CLS 0

Because the task was superseded mid-run and the frontend repair was still in flight, no final LCP verdict is issued here. Fresh Re-QA should repeat mobile Lighthouse after the new production deployment stabilizes.

### Auth / Stripe gate partial recheck

Partial unauthenticated route evidence:

- `/api/auth/login?return_to=/pricing`: 302 to Google OAuth.
- OAuth Location contains `redirect_uri=https://aieditorrsp.net/api/auth/callback/google`.
- `/api/auth/me`: 200 with `{ authenticated: false, user: null }` in a fresh unauthenticated browser context.
- Unauthenticated `POST /api/checkout/stripe?plan=monthly`: 302 to `/api/auth/login?return_to=/api/checkout/stripe?plan=monthly`.
- Invalid Stripe webhook signature probe: 400, as expected.

Accepted upstream evidence still stands under Owner's updated payment gate:

- Host previously verified production OAuth login for `xjtumj@gmail.com`, `/api/auth/me authenticated=true`, and user id `usr__JRNzNQVKYeMtp6bdHXorA`.
- `t_0d6831d7` verified signed Stripe webhook endpoint reachability, signature verification, D1 webhook event logging, live Stripe no-payment event delivery, and idempotency.
- Owner waived real live card payment as a launch gate; first real paid entitlement crediting remains post-launch P1 monitoring.

## Current blockers for fresh QA

P0 / hard gate:

1. `t_2bd28b27` returned `PM_NO_GO` for core editor UX/conversion.
2. `t_f03c74e9` frontend repair was still running when this report was written.
3. Source/deploy state changed during this run; production must be re-verified after repair completion.

P1 / conditional risks to carry into fresh Re-QA:

1. GA4 still absent until a valid Measurement ID or Analytics Admin-capable access is provided and deployed.
2. First real `checkout.session.completed` entitlement crediting remains post-launch P1 monitoring per Owner waiver.
3. Mobile Lighthouse should be repeated after latest deploy; partial run had simulated LCP 3035 ms despite browser LCP <2.5s.

## Next inputs

- Wait for `t_f03c74e9` to complete with commit + push + deploy evidence.
- Wait for Product/design/backend/pricing child tasks from `t_2bd28b27` to resolve or explicitly waive.
- Create a fresh Final Re-QA task after those gates, instead of unblocking this stale run's partial verdict.
- For full `QA_GO` instead of conditional GO, provide `NEXT_PUBLIC_GA_MEASUREMENT_ID` or Analytics Admin-capable access, then redeploy and verify GA4 collect traffic.