# AI Editor RSP — Design Recheck After Deploy

Date: 2026-06-03
Task: t_7c14d39a
Role: moying Design Recheck
Production: https://aieditorrsp.net/
Repo: /root/projects/aieditorrsp

## Verdict

design_verdict: DESIGN_CONDITIONAL_GO

P0 design blockers from the original screenshot are resolved on current production. The right editor console no longer runs past the desktop fold, Generate is visible with margin on all target viewports, and account/payment/credit-plan noise is absent from the first-screen hero.

Conditional status is retained because two non-blocking design/product judgment items remain for downstream review:

1. Mobile hides the left hero CTA row (`Start Editing` / `View Templates`) to keep the editor Generate button above fold. This improves the primary task but deviates from the earlier mobile contract line that asked the CTA row to remain above the editor.
2. The console still uses some flavor-tech labels (`STUDIO_CONSOLE_V01`, `PROMPT_READY`, `IDLE`). They are not the previously forbidden provider/account/billing noise, but product/compliance should decide whether to soften them before final QA.

## Evidence

### Production screenshots captured in this recheck

- /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/design-recheck-screenshots/recheck-1366x768.png
- /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/design-recheck-screenshots/recheck-1440x900.png
- /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/design-recheck-screenshots/recheck-1280x800.png
- /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/design-recheck-screenshots/recheck-390x844.png
- /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/design-recheck-screenshots/recheck-430x932.png

Raw measurement JSON:

- /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/design-recheck-results.json

Measurement script:

- /root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/design-recheck-playwright.mjs

### Browser/viewport measurements

| Viewport | Console top/bottom | Console height | Generate top/bottom | Generate visible + 32px margin | Horizontal overflow | Forbidden first-screen terms | Notes |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---|---|---|---|
| 1366x768 | 124 / 663 | 539 | 418 / 466 | PASS | PASS | none | Desktop P0 fixed; panel fits above fold. |
| 1440x900 | 124 / 663 | 539 | 418 / 466 | PASS | PASS | none | Comfortable vertical whitespace. |
| 1280x800 | 124 / 663 | 539 | 418 / 466 | PASS | PASS | none | Template cards no longer tall/cramped. |
| 390x844 | 227 / 964 | 737 | 720 / 768 | PASS | PASS | none | Generate visible; template strip begins below Generate. |
| 430x932 | 227 / 964 | 737 | 720 / 768 | PASS | PASS | none | Generate visible with large margin. |

Forbidden terms checked:

- Account Credits
- Pro monthly
- Pro yearly
- Credit pack
- 2 free generations left today
- SYSTEM READY
- HD_MODE
- TOKENS:
- server-side provider flow
- /api/credits
- /api/generate-image
- fal processing

Result: none found in viewport or homepage body text during initial production load.

### DOM / structure checks

- Production HTTP: HTTP/2 200.
- Current repo commit: `bad3a84a398c89f967998398471c878be16e9011`.
- Git status: `## main...origin/main`.
- H1 preserved: `AI Image Editor With Prompt Templates`.
- SEO basics preserved: 3 JSON-LD scripts detected; canonical `https://aieditorrsp.net`; OG title present.
- Footer is after main content; SEO expansion is before footer.
- No horizontal overflow at 1366, 1440, 1280, 390, or 430 widths.

## Contract check

PASS:

- Desktop `.studio-hero--tool` is visually aligned at top; H1/hero copy and console top are both y=124 on desktop.
- Desktop console height is 539px, under the 560-620px target range upper bound and under fold.
- Generate button appears above fold and above the template/status area on every tested viewport.
- Full idle/result panel was reduced to a 72px collapsed status hint.
- Account/credits/payment/pricing controls are not in the homepage hero first screen.
- The first-screen task reads as upload source image → describe edit / prompt → Generate edit.
- Mobile is single-column and has no horizontal scroll.

CONDITIONAL:

- Mobile hides the left hero CTA row to prioritize the editor task. If the product owner wants the original mobile CTA-row contract literally enforced, frontend needs a small mobile CTA treatment above or inside the editor.
- Remaining tech-flavor labels are visually small but still code-like. They are acceptable for the current industrial/editor aesthetic, not a design blocker.

## Residual risk

- DESIGN_CONDITIONAL_GO is design-only. Product, SEO, compliance, and final QA still need to run their own rechecks.
- Top nav still contains `Sign In`; compliance/product should confirm auth path truthfulness.
- The production screenshot provided in the user prompt is the old failing state; current production screenshots captured in this recheck show the deployed fix.

## Next inputs

- Product recheck should decide whether mobile hidden left CTAs are acceptable.
- Compliance recheck should decide whether `Sign In` and top-level pricing/auth copy are production-truthful.
- Final QA should use the five screenshots and `design-recheck-results.json` as design evidence.