# AI Editor RSP — Fresh Owner Review Gate after owner repair

- Task: `t_b2457c68`
- Role: 墨策 / Fresh Owner Review Gate
- Production: https://aieditorrsp.net
- Repo: `/root/projects/aieditorrsp`
- Current commit: `4eff4eb80f93cba49e2333a09124d182dbe109c0`
- Deployment source commit: `4eff4eb80f93cba49e2333a09124d182dbe109c0`
- Parent Final QA: `t_f03cad9e`
- Parent Final QA report: `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-owner-repair.md`
- Owner repair brief: `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/owner-repair-brief-20260603.md`
- Prior owner gate rejected: `t_b05228f6`
- Verdict: `OWNER_REVIEW_NOT_READY`
- Launch/public promotion: `BLOCKED`

## Gate decision

Do not generate a new owner approval card yet.

Reason: parent Final QA `t_f03cad9e` is `QA_NO_GO`, while this gate is allowed to generate a new owner acceptance card only after fresh `QA_GO`.

The previous QA_GO remains stale because the owner explicitly rejected the earlier quality. This report is a blocking gate artifact, not a launch approval request.

## Required owner-facing card status

`NOT_SENT_TO_OWNER_FOR_APPROVAL`

Owner approval options are intentionally not opened in this round. Asking the owner to approve now would violate the task contract because Final QA is not green.

## Login / payment status

| Area | Status | Evidence |
|---|---:|---|
| Login entry | PARTIAL / BLOCKING | `/api/auth/login?return_to=/pricing` redirects to Google OAuth. No real OAuth callback/session/logout/D1 user record evidence. |
| Payment / checkout | PARTIAL / BLOCKING | Anonymous checkout redirects to login. No authenticated Stripe Checkout, payment success, webhook, D1 entitlement, or credits/plan upgrade evidence. |
| `/api/credits` | PASS as anonymous API smoke | Returns `authenticated=false`, `plan=free`, `daily_limit=2`, `paid_enabled=true`, checkout options. This does not prove paid flow. |
| `/auth` direct route | FAIL / route decision needed | Direct `/auth` returns 404. Either implement redirect or remove it from acceptance scope. |
| `/checkout` direct route | FAIL / route decision needed | Direct `/checkout` returns 404. Either implement redirect or remove it from acceptance scope. |

## Visual repair evidence

Final QA screenshot artifacts:

- `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-owner-repair-screenshots/desktop1366-editor.png`
- `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-owner-repair-screenshots/mobile390-editor.png`
- `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-owner-repair-screenshots/desktop1366-library.png`
- `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-owner-repair-screenshots/mobile390-templates.png`

Visual status from Final QA:

| Owner issue | Status | Note |
|---|---:|---|
| `/editor` heavy overlay / clipped tool / sidebar | PARTIAL | No horizontal overflow or tool clipping found. Background still visually heavy. Mobile path to Generate remains too long. |
| `/library` content below footer | PASS | Footer is terminal visually; after-footer findings are scripts/route announcer false positives. |
| `/templates` split/overlay/sidebar/header inconsistency | PASS | Mobile layout is single-column, no sidebar/clipping, header matches main site. |
| Unified public header/nav/CTA | PASS | Public pages share the RSP / AI Editor RSP nav system. |

## P1 / P2 repair result

| Item | Current result | Gate impact |
|---|---:|---|
| Duplicate H1 | PASS | `npm run seo:audit` and production DOM checks pass. |
| Short meta descriptions | PASS | `npm run seo:audit` passes 11 routes, 140–160 char descriptions. |
| Sitemap / robots / canonical / schema / alt | PASS | Sitemap smoke: 11 URLs 200, no noindex. |
| GA4 runtime | FAIL / P1 | `ga4=false` in production runtime. Needs configuration or explicit waiver. |
| Clarity runtime | FAIL / P1 | `clarity=false` in production runtime. Needs configuration or explicit waiver. |
| Lighthouse LCP | FAIL / P1 | Mobile LCP 3291.889ms > 2500ms gate. |
| `/editor` mobile Generate below fold | FAIL / P1 | At 390px, Generate remains below the first fold after upload/prompt stack. |
| `/auth` and `/checkout` direct routes | P2/P1 decision | Current 404 may be acceptable only if product/QA scope explicitly removes these public routes. |

## Checks consumed by this owner gate

- `kanban_show(t_b2457c68)`
- `skill_view(kanban-worker)`
- Read owner repair brief: `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/owner-repair-brief-20260603.md`
- Read parent Final QA report: `/root/.hermes/reports/aieditorrsp-hero-optimization-20260603/final-qa-owner-repair.md`
- Read parent Final QA metadata from Kanban handoff
- Checked repo state: `git status --short --branch`, `git rev-parse HEAD`, `git log -1 --oneline`
- Read Final QA evidence JSON header/screenshot paths
- Sent Telegram START visibility update: message_id `851`

No launch, public promotion, payment test, OAuth test, code change, deploy, or external publication was performed in this task.

## Residual risk

- Auth/payment may still fail after consent or checkout because callback, session creation, Stripe success, webhook booking, and D1 entitlement were not proven.
- Analytics will be incomplete unless GA4/Clarity IDs are configured and redeployed, or owner gives an explicit waiver.
- Performance remains below launch gate on mobile LCP.
- Mobile editor still has a longer-than-acceptable path to the Generate action at 390px.
- `/auth` and `/checkout` direct 404 can confuse QA scope or users if any link later points there.
- Launch/public promotion remains blocked until fresh `QA_GO` and a new owner approval gate.

## Next inputs required

1. Backend / owner-supervised auth evidence: Google OAuth callback, session, logout, and D1 user record.
2. Payment evidence: authenticated Stripe Checkout, payment success, webhook, D1 entitlement/credits or plan upgrade.
3. Analytics: configure production GA4 and Clarity IDs, or attach explicit owner waiver.
4. Performance: fix or explicitly waive LCP > 2.5s.
5. Product route decision: implement `/auth` and `/checkout` redirects, or remove direct routes from QA acceptance scope.
6. Frontend/product: reduce `/editor` mobile path-to-generate at 390px, or owner explicitly waives the below-fold Generate issue.

## Reply options once Final QA becomes QA_GO

Only after fresh `QA_GO`, generate an owner acceptance card with these options:

- `APPROVE_LAUNCH`: owner accepts current production quality and permits launch/public promotion.
- `APPROVE_WITH_WAIVERS`: owner accepts named residual risks and permits launch/public promotion with waivers recorded.
- `REQUEST_CHANGES`: owner rejects and lists required changes.
- `PAUSE`: owner pauses the launch path.

Current valid gate state: `WAITING_FINAL_QA_GO`, not `WAITING_OWNER_SITE_APPROVAL`.