# QA 验收报告 - getaiemail
- URL: https://getaiemail.com
- 日期: 2026-05-30
- 验收人: 墨测
- Task: t_e064ee3c
- Tenant: site-getaiemail-20260527
- 结论: ❌ QA_NO_GO

## 结论
getaiemail.com 当前前端核心用户任务基本可用：桌面与 390px 移动端可访问首页和 5 个场景页，生成 subject/body/shorter/warmer/more direct variants、copy toast、unsafe/error/limit 状态均通过；Workers/OpenNext build 通过，Lighthouse 首页表现良好。

但不建议进入上线/运营：analytics collect 完全缺失（无 GA4/Plausible/Clarity/collect 请求）、sitemap 缺少 brief 要求的 `/resignation-email-generator`，且生产可见定价区仍暴露 `placeholder` / `backend billing is enabled` / `sign-in is connected` 等内部状态文案。按本任务要求必须验证 analytics collect，因此判定 QA_NO_GO。

## 输入读取
- 已读取 brief: `/root/.hermes/reports/site-getaiemail-20260527/input-brief.md`
- Brief 核心要求：AI Email Generator for Work Emails；URL 矩阵 10 个页面；选择场景 → 填 recipient/purpose/tone/key points → 输出 subject + email body + shorter/warmer/more direct variants → one-click copy；cold email 不鼓励 spam。

## 验证范围
### 桌面 + 移动端真实浏览器
- 桌面 1440px：首页 + 5 个场景页
- 移动 390px：首页 + 5 个场景页
- 场景页：`/cold-email-generator`、`/follow-up-email-generator`、`/professional-email-generator`、`/sales-email-generator`、`/reply-email-generator`
- 额外 HTTP/SEO routes：全部 brief 矩阵、legal、login、checkout、robots、sitemap、API deferred endpoint

### 真实用户任务
- follow-up：输入 Dana/BrightOps + demo feedback → 生成包含输入内容的 subject/body/variants，copy subject toast 通过
- professional：launch readiness update → 生成通过
- sales：workflow automation idea → 生成通过
- reply：timeline clarification → 生成通过
- meeting：review meeting → 生成通过
- cold unsafe：`scrape/bulk send spam/bypass consent/impersonate` → safety refusal 通过
- error state：`trigger error` → recoverable error 通过
- limit state：3/3 preview limit → limit copy 通过
- pricing toggle：Monthly / Yearly 切换可用
- checkout placeholder：`/checkout?billing=annual` 安全静态占位，不收集付款信息

## 功能验收
| 项目 | 状态 | 备注 |
|---|---|---|
| Landing Page | PASS | H1、CTA、工具、场景入口、FAQ、Footer 均可见 |
| SEO 矩阵页 | FAIL | 10 个矩阵 route 均 200，但 sitemap 只有 13 URL，缺 `/resignation-email-generator` |
| 核心工具 | PASS(frontend-only) | 生成、variants、copy、unsafe/error/limit 均通过；当前为 deterministic frontend draft，不是真 AI API |
| 用户系统 | DEFERRED | `/login` 是安全占位；未收集凭证；真实 auth deferred |
| 支付 | DEFERRED / UX_FAIL | `/checkout` 是安全占位；未收集支付；但生产文案暴露 placeholder/internal readiness 状态 |
| Workers-first | PASS(frontend-only) | `npm run worker:build` 通过；wrangler 部署存在；无 D1/KV/R2/API binding |

## UI/UX
| 项目 | 状态 | 备注 |
|---|---|---|
| 1440px 桌面 | PASS | 双栏 hero/tool、桌面 nav、scenario rail、pricing、FAQ/footer 可见 |
| 390px 移动端 | PASS | 首页 + 5 个场景页无水平溢出，generator 可用，header 保留 SIGN IN/GENERATE |
| 视觉占位 | FAIL | 定价区可见 `START ANNUAL PRO PLACEHOLDER`、`Frontend-only checkout placeholder`、`backend billing is enabled`、`sign-in is connected` |
| 反 AI 味 | PASS | 未见 lorem/stitch 残留；整体视觉统一 |

## 性能
Lighthouse 首页：
- Performance: 100
- Accessibility: 96
- Best Practices: 100
- SEO: 100
- LCP: 1.7s
- CLS: 0
- TBT: 60ms

HTTP route 响应：主要 HTML route 85–400ms 级别；无浏览器 console error / pageerror。

## SEO 基础
- `<title>` / meta description / canonical / OG title：主要页面存在
- H1：每页 1 个
- robots.txt：200
- sitemap.xml：200
- 问题：sitemap 缺 `/resignation-email-generator`，与 brief URL matrix 不一致

## Analytics / collect
状态: FAIL
- 页面脚本中未发现 GA4 / GTM / Plausible / Clarity / analytics 脚本
- 真实浏览器操作中未观察到 collect/analytics 请求
- 工具内部只 dispatch `getaiemail:event` 自定义事件（tool_start/tool_result），未上报到可用 analytics backend

## 安全 / 合规
- HTTPS production route 可访问
- cold/sales 场景有 permission-based / anti-spam 口径
- unsafe 输入拒绝通过
- `/api/generate`、`/api/health` 返回 404：符合当前 frontend-only deferred 范围，但不满足真实 AI API launch
- legal routes：privacy/terms/cookie/refund 均 200

## 阻断问题
| ID | 严重性 | 描述 | 责任人 |
|---|---|---|---|
| QA-BLOCK-001 | P1/P0 Launch | analytics collect 缺失：无 GA4/Plausible/Clarity/collect 请求，无法满足本任务 analytics collect 验收 | 前端/运营埋点 |
| QA-BLOCK-002 | P1 SEO | sitemap.xml 缺 `/resignation-email-generator`，brief URL matrix 与 sitemap 不一致 | 前端/SEO |
| QA-BLOCK-003 | P1 UX/Trust | 生产定价区暴露 placeholder/internal 状态文案：`START ANNUAL PRO PLACEHOLDER`、`Frontend-only checkout placeholder`、`backend billing is enabled`、`sign-in is connected` | 前端/产品 |

## 非阻断残留风险
- 真实 AI API、auth、quota ledger、payment/webhook 仍 deferred；当前只能按 frontend-only 工具验收，不能作为真实 AI SaaS 付费上线验收。
- Cloudflare deployment Source 仍为 Unknown/direct upload；通过 origin/main clean + local build + deployed route 验证兜底。
- 默认静态 sample 输出仍是 Sarah，与默认 recipient “Hiring manager at Acme” 不一致；实际点击生成后会反映输入，建议优化默认展示一致性。

## artifact_paths
- `/root/.hermes/reports/site-getaiemail-20260527/qa/t_e064ee3c/final-qa-report.md`
- `/root/.hermes/reports/site-getaiemail-20260527/qa/t_e064ee3c/playwright-final-qa.json`
- `/root/.hermes/reports/site-getaiemail-20260527/qa/t_e064ee3c/lighthouse-home.json`
- `/root/.hermes/reports/site-getaiemail-20260527/qa/t_e064ee3c/screenshots/`
- `/root/.hermes/kanban/boards/site-factory/workspaces/t_e064ee3c/final_qa_playwright.mjs`

## verification
- `npm run verify`: PASS (`ok=true`, routes=16, scenarioRoutes=9, legalRoutes=4, runtime_architecture=workers_first_frontend_only)
- `npm run typecheck`: PASS
- `npm run build`: PASS, Next.js generated 20 pages
- `npm run worker:build`: PASS, OpenNext worker saved in `.open-next/worker.js`
- `git fetch origin main`; HEAD = origin/main = `1e811e6ee589dbe0ff6a1065f51c04271f20863a`
- HTTP smoke：核心 route/legal/robots/sitemap 200；`/api/generate`、`/api/health` 404 deferred
- Playwright production QA：5 个用户任务 + unsafe/error/limit + desktop/mobile responsive PASS；analytics FAIL
- Lighthouse production homepage：PASS
- Browser vision 1440px：layout PASS；placeholder pricing copy flagged

## acceptance_checklist
| 检查项 | 结果 |
|---|---|
| input brief read | PASS |
| homepage main keyword positioning | PASS |
| all required matrix routes HTTP 200 | PASS |
| sitemap contains required matrix | FAIL: missing `/resignation-email-generator` |
| homepage + >=5 scenario pages desktop browser | PASS |
| homepage + >=5 scenario pages 390px browser | PASS |
| scenario structured inputs | PASS |
| subject + body output | PASS |
| shorter/warmer/more direct variants | PASS |
| one-click copy | PASS: clipboard write intercepted + toast |
| unsafe/spam refusal | PASS |
| error state | PASS |
| speed/performance | PASS |
| SEO basics | PARTIAL: page metadata pass, sitemap mismatch fail |
| analytics collect | FAIL |
| auth/payment CTAs safe | PASS as deferred placeholders |
| production-ready pricing copy | FAIL |
| Workers/OpenNext build | PASS |
| real backend/API health | DEFERRED: 404 by current frontend-only scope |

## residual_risk
- Analytics/data pipeline unavailable; cannot hand to operations for traffic observation.
- SEO sitemap mismatch may delay/omit indexing for resignation route.
- Placeholder payment/internal readiness copy harms trust if production traffic sees pricing.
- Backend/auth/payment/API deferred means future real-AI launch requires new backend/payment/security/compliance QA.

## next_inputs
1. Add production analytics integration and verify at least page_view + tool_start/tool_result or tool_complete + pricing_cta_click collect requests; ensure no PII.
2. Add `/resignation-email-generator` to sitemap.xml and rerun sitemap route smoke.
3. Replace user-facing placeholder/internal pricing copy with launch-safe wording, while preserving honest “no payment collected yet” only if this is intentionally a waitlist/demo build.
4. If moving beyond frontend-only: provide `/api/generate` contract, AI provider/model, server-side safety filter, rate limit/quota plan, auth/session strategy, payment/webhook implementation, and D1/KV/R2/secrets evidence.
5. Rerun narrow Re-QA on analytics, sitemap, pricing copy, and regression for core generation/copy/unsafe/error/limit.