# Owner Review Gate after final remediation Re-QA - Subnautica2Maps

- Task: t_9375d801
- Tenant: site-rerun-subnautica2maps-20260520-stitch-sdk-clean
- Production URL: https://subnautica2maps.com/
- Parent QA task: t_d8108746
- Parent QA report: /root/.hermes/kanban/boards/site-factory/workspaces/t_d8108746/reports/site-pipeline/site-rerun-subnautica2maps-20260520-stitch-sdk-clean/subnautica2maps/09-final-remediation-reqa.md
- Verification time: 2026-05-21T08:52:00+00:00
- Parent go_no_go: QA_NO_GO
- Owner approval request sent: NO
- Gate verdict: QA_NOT_GO_AFTER_REMEDIATION

## Decision

Do not ask Meng Jian for launch approval yet.

This owner review gate is explicitly conditional on parent `t_d8108746` returning `QA_GO`. The parent final Re-QA still returns `QA_NO_GO`, so the correct action is to block this task with `QA_NOT_GO_AFTER_REMEDIATION` and wait for remediation + a new final Re-QA.

The watchdog auto-unblocked this task because all parents are done, but parent done != QA_GO. The task rule is stricter than dependency completion.

## Passed items from final Re-QA

- Production `/map/` Lighthouse passes: Performance 92, Accessibility 100, Best Practices 100, SEO 100, LCP 2.3s, CLS 0.
- `/privacy` and `/terms` now 308 redirect to `/privacy-policy/` and `/terms-of-service/`.
- Plausible production script and map event call chain are present; backend/dashboard ingestion was not verified.
- Real-user `/map/` tasks pass: open map, search, filter, marker detail, approximate route, pan/zoom, local found, source/confidence/updated metadata.
- 390px and 1440px visual regressions improved enough for core task usability.

## Remaining launch blockers

| ID | Severity | Issue | Owner / card |
|---|---|---|---|
| QA-003 | P1 | `subnautica2maps.com` has no MX records while production footer/privacy expose `hello@subnautica2maps.com`; contact email cannot be verified as receivable. | 墨运/Host, t_171f29bf |
| QA-007 | P1 | Production `/map/` repeatedly emits React hydration/text mismatch pageerrors: `Minified React error #418`. Site QA requires console/page errors = 0. | 墨界, t_f7ab6ccc |

## Residual P2 / polish items

| ID | Severity | Issue | Owner / card |
|---|---|---|---|
| QA-004R | P2 | 390px mobile bottom sheet remains crowded and pushes detail content below the first viewport. | 墨界, t_f7ab6ccc |
| QA-006R | P2 | 1440px desktop marker cluster remains visually dense, although map-first layout is usable. | 墨界, t_f7ab6ccc |

## Residual risks

- Plausible dashboard/backend ingestion was not verified; only production script, event calls, and browser network/performance beacons were observed.
- GA4/Clarity/Ahrefs are not present. Current privacy copy only discloses Plausible, so this is acceptable unless launch requires those tools later.

## Owner review URL pack

Prepared but not sent because QA_GO condition is not met:

- Homepage: https://subnautica2maps.com/
- Map: https://subnautica2maps.com/map/
- Privacy: https://subnautica2maps.com/privacy-policy/
- Terms: https://subnautica2maps.com/terms-of-service/
- Robots: https://subnautica2maps.com/robots.txt
- Sitemap: https://subnautica2maps.com/sitemap.xml

## Core `/map` inspection tasks for future owner review

Only send these after a new Re-QA returns `QA_GO`:

1. Open `https://subnautica2maps.com/map/?q=silver`.
2. Search `copper` and confirm list/map update.
3. Toggle Resources / POIs / Black Boxes filters.
4. Open `Cicada Wreck - Lander Garage` and inspect coordinates, depth, biome, source, updated, confidence.
5. Use `Calculate approximate route` from a coordinate input.
6. Pan/zoom the map.
7. Use `Mark Local Found` and confirm local progress persists.
8. Check 390px mobile bottom sheet usability.

## Launch recommendation

NO_GO for owner approval request now.

Next required action: complete remediation cards `t_f7ab6ccc` and `t_171f29bf`, then run a new final Re-QA. Only if the new Re-QA metadata reports `go_no_go=QA_GO` should this gate send Meng Jian the explicit approval options:

- `确认上线 t_9375d801`
- `返修 t_9375d801: ...`
- `暂停 t_9375d801`